Holiday

Ice Cream Pies

ICE CREAM IS PERFECT FOR ANY OCCASION

$18 for one 10" pie

or 2 pies for $35

Last Day for Orders- December 19th

Pickup at the Vintage Cow  

Please Allow two days to process orders and create pies

Payment Due at Pickup​

Pumpkin Snap Pie

Ginger snap crust with Pumpkin Snap Ice Cream, decorated with sweet cream and drizzled with caramel. 

Coconut Almond Crunch Pie

Chocolate crumb crust, Coconut Almond Ice Cream, decorated with sweet cream, drizzled with fudge and dusted with toasted coconut

Mint Chocolate Chunk

Chocolate graham crust with Mint Chocolate Chunk ice cream topped with sweet cream, drizzled with fudge, and Andes candies

Cow Tracks

Chocolate graham crust with Cow Tracks ice cream topped with sweet cream, drizzled with fudge, and sprinkled with chopped peanut butter cups. 

Dirty Egg Nog

Oreo Crust, Egg Nog Ice Cream topped with sweet cream and drizzled with  fudge 

Peppermint Fudge

Oreo crust, peppermint fudge ice cream topped with sweet cream frosting and crushed candy canes

Peppermint Stick

Golden Oreo crust, peppermint stick ice cream topped with sweet cream and crushed candy canes

Holiday Ice Cream Pies

What Pie Would You Like?

Pumpkin Snap Pie
Coconut Almond Crunch
Mint Chocolate Chunk
Cow Tracks
Dirt Egg Nog
Peppermint Fudge
Peppermint Stick
arrow&v
arrow&v
arrow&v
arrow&v
arrow&v
arrow&v
arrow&v
arrow&v

Ice Cream

The Vintage Cow Farmer’s Market LLC proudly scoops and twists ice cream hand-crafted by PittsfordFarms Dairy in Pittsford, NY. Pittsford Farms Dairy is a creamery that bottles their own milk and handcrafts their own ice cream using in house recipes to make the smoothest, creamiest ice cream you canfind. The custard ice cream is a true custard recipe made with egg and the hard ice cream flavors arecrafted using the finest ingredients such as true vanilla and fair trade chocolate. Delectable, frozentreats on our menu include: custard in flavors vanilla, chocolate or twist, 8 hard flavors of ice cream thatwe rotate on a regular basis, milk shakes, floats, and flurries. Try our Vintage Cow Signature Sundaemade with Cow Tracks ice cream, hot fudge and topped with whipped cream, a cherry and cow shapedsprinkles! If your sweet tooth would like to try something different we offer pie a la mode made with in-season fruit pie from Kim’s Seasonal Sweets. Kim also makes our homemade Strawberry, StrawberryRhubarb and Blackberry sauce toppings. We offer a variety of toppings including cow shaped sprinkles,Attica Blue Devil sprinkles and Alexander Trojan sprinkles. Seating is available in our Greenhouse whereyou can watch kids play in the corn box or try to beat your buddy at a game of checkers. We welcomeyou to pay a visit, bring some friends or family, relax and enjoy! Our motto is “Premium taste, VintageExperience.”