Ice Cream

Premium taste, Vintage Experience

The Vintage Cow Farmer’s Market LLC proudly scoops and twists ice cream hand-crafted by Pittsford Farms Dairy in Pittsford, NY. Pittsford Farms Dairy is a creamery that bottles their own milk and handcrafts their own ice cream using in house recipes to make the smoothest, creamiest ice cream you can find. The custard ice cream is a true custard recipe made with egg and the hard ice cream flavors are crafted using the finest ingredients such as true vanilla and fair trade chocolate. Delectable, frozen treats on our menu include: custard in flavors vanilla, chocolate or twist, 8 hard flavors of ice cream that we rotate on a regular basis, milk shakes, floats, and flurries. Try our Vintage Cow Signature Sundae made with Cow Tracks ice cream, hot fudge and topped with whipped cream, a cherry and cow shaped sprinkles! If your sweet tooth would like to try something different we offer pie a la mode made with in-season fruit pie from Kim’s Seasonal Sweets. Kim also makes our homemade Strawberry, Strawberry Rhubarb and Blackberry sauce toppings. We offer a variety of toppings including cow shaped sprinkles,Attica Blue Devil sprinkles and Alexander Trojan sprinkles. Seating is available in our Greenhouse where you can watch kids play in the corn box or try to beat your buddy at a game of checkers. We welcome you to pay a visit, bring some friends or family, relax and enjoy! Our motto is “Premium taste, Vintage Experience.”


Address: 11105 Route 98 Alexander Road

Attica, New York 14011

Phone: 585.250.2704



Greenhouse Open Regular Mon-Sat. 10-8pm and Sun.1-8 for shopping but we will be limiting how many people in at a time. 

Ice Cream will be open Mon-Sat 12-9pm and Sunday 1-9pm. We will have designated parking for Ice Cream Customers we ask that you please stay in your car . We will take your order car side and deliver it to your vehicle. We will offer our full menu along with hand packed pints and Ice Cream Sundae Kits to go that can be preordered online if you would like.