Christmas Holiday Pies

9" Pie

$18 each

6" $8 each

Please Pre-Order by 12/16  and select a Pick Up Day when Ordering

Please Pay at Pick Up



Peppermint Fudge-Oreo Crust, Peppermint Ice Cream with Fudge Swirls, Decorated with Whipped Cream Icing, Drizzled with Hot Fudge and Sprinkled with Chopped Candy Canes


Pepper Mint Stick- Oreo Crust (specify Golden Oreos or Regular Oreos for crust) Peppermint Ice Cream with Peppermint Stick Pieces, Decorated with Whipped Cream Icing, Sprinkled with Candy Cane Pieces


Dirty Egg Nog- Oreo Crust, Dirty Egg Nog Ice Cream (Egg Nog Ice Cream with Mini Chocolate Chips and Oreo Pieces), Decorated with Whipped Cream Icincg and Drizzled with Fudge


Coconut Almond Crunch-Oreo Crust, Coconut Almond Ice Cream, Decorated with Whipped Cream Icing, Drizzled with Fudge and Sprinkled with Toasted Coconut

6"-Christmas Ice Cream Pies

Pick Up Day

    Address: 11105 Route 98 Alexander Road

    Attica, New York 14011

    Phone: 585.250.2704


    Closing for our regular Season Saturday 10/31! 

    Re-Opening Friday 11/27  11am-7pm with Christmas Trees, Wreaths, Poinsettias, Christmas Cactus, Gifts, Holiday Ice Cream & Pittsford Dairy Egg Nog!

    Monday-Friday 3pm-7pm

    Saturday-Sunday 11am-6pm


    Due to Covid-19 we ask that you please wear a mask while shopping with us and please follow Social Distancing Practices.