Ice Cream Shop

Be Sure to Check Out Our Handcrafted Ice Cream!

If you love the flavor and texture of handcrafted ice cream, be sure to stop by the ice cream shop at the Vintage Cow Farmer’s Market. We offer a wide range of delicious flavors that are handcrafted by Pittsford Farms Dairy, located in Pittsford, NY. This amazing creamery bottles its own milk and specializes in making its own line of handcrafted ice cream using family recipes. It’s by far the creamiest, best-tasting ice cream you’ll ever try! Check out the custard ice cream, made using a traditional custard recipe with eggs. All of the delicious flavors are crafted using only the finest ingredients like real vanilla, fair-trade chocolate, and more.

Check out our ice cream shop to discover your new favorite treats. We offer a variety of delicious options including custard in flavors of chocolate, vanilla, or twist and hard flavors of ice cream that are constantly being updated to keep things fresh and new. You’ll also find delectable old-fashioned milkshakes and floats. Try a flurry and don’t forget to include all of your favorite toppings. Our signature Vintage Cow Sundae is made with delicious hot fudge, Cow Tracks ice cream, and topped with luscious whipped cream and sweet cherry sprinkles.

Some of our most popular flavors include the classic chocolate/vanilla twist Pittsford Dairy custard, gluten-free chocolate, vanilla bean, and mint chocolate chunk hard ice cream. We also have Cow Tracks hard ice cream, coconut almond crunch, cookie monster, cookies and cream, chocolate chip cookie dough, blue moo, and more! You can check out our latest flavor offerings on our Facebook page, and be sure to follow us, so you know all about our newest specials. When it comes to the best local handcrafted ice cream, you can’t go wrong with a visit to the ice cream shop at The Vintage Cow Farmer’s Market!